

Photos: Eleuthera by Trish Hartmann, CC BY 2.0, cropped; Islamorada by Pietro Valocchi, CC BY 3.0, cropped.
Eleuthera or Islamorada?
Our verdict in twelve categories, each scored against the same fixed benchmark cities, and the climate month by month, so you can choose for your trip.
Choose Eleuthera for
- beaches
- culture and sights
Eleuthera is the pick for anyone whose ideal day is spent on a near-empty beach. Pale-pink Atlantic strands run down one side, glassy coves line the Bight on the other, and Pink Sands lies just across the water on Harbour Island, which is far more sand than Islamorada can offer. The island is quieter too. In return you accept long drives down a single highway and a thin choice of places to eat.
Choose Islamorada for
- nature and the outdoors
- day trips
- families
Travellers who would rather spend the day on a boat than on a towel will be happier in Islamorada. Its flats fishing, reef snorkelling and mangrove paddling are richer and easier to reach, and families find more to do. Key Largo is close by road, while Key West makes one long day out to the south. What Islamorada lacks is a real beach: the shore is mangrove and seagrass, and the best sand is a drive away.
Scoreboard
Twelve categories on one fixed scale from 0 to 100. The shaded stretch is the gap between the two.
Your match
Pick a travel style or drag the sliders, and both match scores follow your weighting.
Too close to call, 2 points apart
Wins on beaches and culture and sights with your weighting.
Wins on nature and the outdoors and day trips with your weighting.
What matters to you?
Category by category
What the scores mean for a trip.
Beaches & swimming
Beaches are what Eleuthera is built around, and here Islamorada cannot compete. On Eleuthera you choose between pale-pink Atlantic strands such as French Leave, with reef offshore and surf on breezy days, and the still, shallow water of the Bight. Pink Sands on Harbour Island adds about 5km more. Facilities are few, so bring your own shade.
The water off Islamorada is just as warm, but the shoreline is mangrove, rock and seagrass. Anne's Beach and the roadside parks are narrow wading spots. Locals go by boat to the sandbar off Whale Harbor instead, or drive about an hour to Bahia Honda for proper sand.
Food & drink
Both islands cook mostly fish and conch, but Islamorada gives you more of it and makes it easier to find. Same-day snapper, grouper and hogfish, stone crab claws in winter and key lime pie are served on decks over the water. Many kitchens will cook the fish you caught, and there are raw bars and local breweries too.
Eleuthera's best meals are cracked conch, conch salad and fried fish at the weekly fish fries, along with the sweet pineapples from Gregory Town. Outside Harbour Island's expensive resort restaurants the choice is thin, and kitchens often close early. Self-caterers should expect limited, imported groceries.
Culture & sights
Neither is a culture trip, and on both you can see the sights in a day or two. What differs is the story they tell. Eleuthera's is the history of its settlers: Preacher's Cave, where Puritans from Bermuda sheltered in the 1640s, the Loyalist clapboard cottages of Dunmore Town and the Victorian houses of Governor's Harbour.
Islamorada's story is about the sea and the railway. It is told at the History of Diving Museum and the 1935 Hurricane Monument, and in the ruins of the old wrecking settlement on Indian Key, which you reach by kayak or boat.
Nightlife
Both go quiet early, so the difference lies in what an evening is like. On Eleuthera the social nights are the weekly fish fries, with rake-and-scrape music and rum, plus Harbour Island's beach bars and a dance bar that fills up at weekends in season. Islamorada has no clubs; its evenings are sunset drinks on tiki decks along the highway, louder at weekends with the boating crowd and over well before the charters leave at dawn.
Nature & outdoors
Both are water destinations with little land to hike, but Islamorada's water offers more. The Florida Bay flats are celebrated for bonefish, tarpon and permit, and the Gulf Stream brings sailfish and tuna. Alligator Reef and Pennekamp have clear water for snorkelling, mangrove paddles pass manatees and rays, and boats run out into the Everglades backcountry.
Eleuthera has its own highlights: the Glass Window rock bridge between the deep Atlantic and the green Bight, the tidal Queen's Baths, bonefish flats, and drift dives through Current Cut and over the Devil's Backbone wrecks. The choice is narrower, and paddling is best on the calm western side.
Day trips
Islamorada has more places to drive to. Key West is a long but rewarding day out to the south, with the Turtle Hospital in Marathon and the old railway bridges along the way. Key Largo is close by to the north, and Miami is further off.
Eleuthera's outings are by water taxi. Harbour Island's pastel cottages and the fishing settlement of Spanish Wells are both minutes from the North Eleuthera docks and make a good pair. Beyond those there is the fast ferry to Nassau, which makes a long day, and otherwise the settlements and beaches of the main island.
Good for families
Islamorada gives families more to fill the days. Small children can paddle on the warm flats, Theater of the Sea has sea lion and dolphin shows, and feeding the tarpon at the docks rarely fails. Resort pools cover the rest, though days built around boat charters suit older children best.
Eleuthera has better beaches for a quiet family week, especially the calm western coves. But nothing there is aimed at children, every outing means a drive, the Atlantic beaches can have rip currents, and serious medical cases are flown to Nassau. It works best for self-reliant families with older children.
Getting around
You need a car on both, but the distances are very different. Islamorada stretches about 30km along one easy road, with a paved cycle trail beside much of it and boats for the rest, though weekend traffic slows it down.
Eleuthera's Queen's Highway runs about 180km, with potholed stretches and no buses. Choose your base with care and fly into whichever of its three airports is nearest. Harbour Island is the exception: small enough to walk or get around by golf cart.
Shopping & style
Neither island is a place to go shopping, and on both an afternoon covers what is on offer. The difference is what you come home with. On Eleuthera, shopping mostly means clothes for the island and something made on it: linen and beachwear in the small shops of Dunmore Town, woven straw hats and bags, and island paintings. Away from Harbour Island it shrinks to the odd craft stop on the drive between settlements.
Islamorada's shops follow the fishing it is known for. Anglers can lose a morning in its big, long-established tackle and outdoor outfitter, and even the galleries lean towards marine art. The rest is roadside souvenirs. If you want resort clothes and handmade keepsakes, Harbour Island is the better bet. If you are kitting out for the flats, Islamorada is.
Affordability
Both are expensive, for different reasons. On Eleuthera nearly everything arrives by boat, so groceries, meals and fuel cost well above mainland levels, and the hire car you need every day adds up. A main-island cottage where you cook for yourself is the thriftiest way to stay, while Harbour Island is the costliest part.
In Islamorada the bill grows through high-season room rates and through the activities themselves: charters, boat rentals and dive trips. Summer is cheaper.
Live music & performing arts
Neither has a theatre or concert hall, so on both islands live music usually means a guitarist at a bar. Eleuthera has more in the way of community traditions: Junkanoo parades on Christmas Day, costumed groups along the Dunmore Town bayfront on Boxing Day and New Year's Day, and music and dancing at Gregory Town's Pineapple Festival in early summer. Islamorada has only the occasional community concert, and for a proper show you drive to Miami or Key West.
Wellness & relaxation
Both islands restore you through their slow pace rather than any bathing tradition, and on both you find spas only at resorts. Eleuthera is the quieter of the two, with long empty days and dark nights, but outside Harbour Island and Cape Eleuthera pampering means booking a therapist. Islamorada's waterfront resorts have full spas with open-air cabanas and sunrise yoga on the docks, and fit into days that start early and end at sunset.
When should you go?
Pick your month. The climate figures are measured averages, not a forecast.
Eleuthera in July
Islamorada in July
Daytime high, °C
Rainfall in the month, mm
Where the figures come from
Eleuthera has no weather station within reach, so its figures come from a gridded climate model rather than a measured record, and read a broad area rather than one spot.
Islamorada's temperatures are measured 63 km from the centre, at Key West Airport.
Islamorada has no rain gauge within 25 km of the centre, so its rainfall comes from a gridded climate dataset read at the destination rather than from a gauge further away.
Temperature and rainfall are climate normals, averaged over the years shown. Eleuthera: 2001-2020 normals, NASA POWER reanalysis grid, no weather station within 90 km. Islamorada: 1991-2020 (sunshine 1981-2010) normals, Key West Airport (63.3 km from centre).
Both islands are at their best from December to April, when rain is light and the days are warm rather than hot. On Eleuthera the sea stays around 24°C even in midwinter, so you can swim in any month. From May the rain picks up and peaks at about 145mm in September, but daytime highs stay in the high twenties, so summer beach days remain comfortable.
Islamorada runs hotter. By July and August afternoons reach 32°C, too warm for much beyond the water. June is the wettest month at 182mm, and the months either side are stormy too. Spring is its sweet spot: April brings long sunny days and little rain before the heat builds. Through the summer the sea is bath-warm off both islands.
Which traveller are you?
On a beach and sun trip, Eleuthera is the clear choice. Long pink-sand Atlantic beaches, calm swimming coves on the Bight and Harbour Island's Pink Sands are often almost empty. Most of Islamorada's shore is mangrove and seagrass, with only narrow strips of sand.
For an outdoors trip built around the water, Islamorada comes out ahead. Its Florida Bay flats are famous for tarpon and permit, and the Gulf Stream brings sailfish offshore. Alligator Reef, Pennekamp's underwater park and the mangrove channels are all close to the highway.
On a family trip with children, Islamorada is the easier base. The shallow flats suit small paddlers, Theater of the Sea and the tarpon feeding put on a show, and resort pools fill the afternoons. Eleuthera has calm coves but nothing built for children.
Before you go
| Measure | Eleuthera | Islamorada |
|---|---|---|
| Official language | English | - |
| Currency | Bahamian Dollar (BSD) | US Dollar (USD) |
| Sockets | ||
| Driving side | Left | Right |
| Time zone | UTC-5, UTC-4 in summer | UTC-5, UTC-4 in summer |
| Emergency number | 919 | 911 |
| Main airport | North Eleuthera Airport (ELH)7 non-stop destinations | Miami International Airport (MIA)198 non-stop destinations |
| Public holidays this year | 11 days | 11 days |
By the numbers
| Measure | Eleuthera | Islamorada |
|---|---|---|
| Population | 8,164 | 7,107 |
| People per km² | 16 | 418 |
| Swim season, months above 21 °C | 12 months | 12 months |
Where else could you go?
Every comparison below shares a destination with this one, so you can follow Eleuthera or Islamorada somewhere new.
- Key Largovs Islamorada
- Marathonvs Islamorada
- Evergladesvs Islamorada
- Exumavs Eleuthera
- Sanibelvs Islamorada
- Siesta Keyvs Islamorada