

Photos: Eleuthera by Trish Hartmann, CC BY 2.0, cropped; Marathon by Yinan Chen, Public domain.
Eleuthera or Marathon?
Our verdict in twelve categories, each scored against the same fixed benchmark cities, and the climate month by month, so you can choose for your trip.
Choose Eleuthera for
- beaches
- shopping
- nightlife
Eleuthera is for travellers who put the beach first and want plenty of space on it. Pink Atlantic strands, glassy coves on the Bight and the long sweep of Pink Sands on Harbour Island give it far better sand and swimming. In return you accept thin dining, a long drive down a single potholed road and nothing much organised. It suits couples and self-sufficient travellers who want to read, swim and switch off, and who can afford an island where everything arrives by boat.
Choose Marathon for
- families
- getting around
- nature and the outdoors
Marathon makes more sense when the water matters more to you than the sand. It is a working base for the reef, the flats and offshore fishing, with marinas, charters and kayak routes close at hand. Families with animal-loving children have the turtle and dolphin centres, and Key West and Islamorada are both within a drive for a change of scene. The beaches are narrower and the setting less striking, but it is easier to reach, easier to fill your days and a little gentler on the wallet.
Scoreboard
Twelve categories on one fixed scale from 0 to 100. The shaded stretch is the gap between the two.
Your match
Pick a travel style or drag the sliders, and both match scores follow your weighting.
Too close to call, 2 points apart
Wins on beaches and shopping with your weighting.
Wins on families and getting around with your weighting.
What matters to you?
Category by category
What the scores mean for a trip.
Beaches & swimming
This is Eleuthera's great advantage. It has two very different coasts. On the Atlantic side, beaches such as French Leave and Lighthouse Beach have pinkish sand and some surf, while the Bight side has still, shallow coves. Across the water, Pink Sands on Harbour Island runs for about 5km. Often only a few other people share a beach.
Marathon's shoreline is narrow and protected by the reef, and in places seagrass reaches the waterline. Sombrero Beach is pleasant for an afternoon, and Bahia Honda across the Seven Mile Bridge is the one beach that comes near Eleuthera's. Many visitors in Marathon get their best swimming by jumping off a boat over the reef.
Food & drink
On both islands the food comes from the sea and is simple, but Marathon makes it easier to eat well. You eat at picnic tables on marina waterfronts, and the menus run to blackened mahi, Keys pink shrimp, stone crab in the cooler months and key lime pie. Some fish markets will cook the fish you caught that day.
Eleuthera's best meals are cracked conch, conch salad made to order and the weekly fish fries. Away from a handful of expensive kitchens on Harbour Island, though, there is little choice and restaurants keep irregular hours. Self-caterers also find the imported groceries limited.
Culture & sights
Neither is a culture destination, and either can be seen in an afternoon or two, but their history is quite different. Eleuthera's goes back to the settlers who sheltered in Preacher's Cave in the 1640s. Dunmore Town has clapboard Loyalist cottages and Governor's Harbour has Victorian houses, so there are streets worth walking.
In Marathon the story is engineering: Flagler's Overseas Railroad, told through the workers' cottages on Pigeon Key and the old Seven Mile Bridge, plus the pioneer house at Crane Point. Marathon has no old town to wander, which is why people who want one drive to Key West.
Nightlife
Evenings on both are quiet, centred on sundowners and an early night. On Eleuthera, Harbour Island has beach bars and a dance bar that fill up at weekends in season, and the fish fries on the main island keep going with music and rum.
In Marathon you watch the sunset from a tiki bar among anglers who will be up before dawn. Its advantage is that Duval Street in Key West is about an hour's drive away when you want a proper night out.
Nature & outdoors
Marathon is the stronger base for time on the water. Sombrero Reef lies a few miles out in a protected marine sanctuary, and the fishing ranges from tarpon on the flats to sailfish offshore. On calm days you can paddle the mangroves at Curry Hammock, cycle the Overseas Heritage Trail or look for Key deer on Big Pine Key.
Eleuthera's landscape is more striking. At the Glass Window a thin rock bridge separates the dark Atlantic from the green Bight, and the Queen's Baths are rock pools filled by the tide. Under water it offers drift dives through Current Cut and wrecks on Devil's Backbone. The good spots are spread over a long island, and neither place has much hiking.
Day trips
Marathon has more to drive to. Key West, about an hour down the Overseas Highway, has its conch-house old town, Hemingway's home and the sunset at Mallory Square, and Islamorada and Bahia Honda are also within reach.
Day trips from Eleuthera go by boat. Short water-taxi rides take you to Harbour Island, with its pastel cottages and boutiques, and to Spanish Wells, a close-knit fishing settlement. Nassau is a long day by fast ferry, so most days on Eleuthera are spent on beaches rather than going anywhere.
Good for families
Marathon gives children more to do. The Turtle Hospital and the Dolphin Research Center on Grassy Key are things to see, not just more time on the beach. Crane Point's trails and children's museum and the shallow, shaded water at Sombrero Beach add to them, and snorkel trips and glass-bottom boats fill the remaining days.
Eleuthera has the sheltered coves of the Bight and roomy rented cottages, but almost nothing organised. There are rip currents on the Atlantic side, and serious medical cases are flown to Nassau. It suits older, independent children better than toddlers.
Getting around
You will need a car on both, but Marathon is easier. Everything lies along one highway, a bike path follows much of the town, and the drive down from Miami takes about two and a half hours. Boats to the reef leave from the many marinas.
On Eleuthera the Queen's Highway is about 180km long, potholed in places, and there is no public transport. It helps to fly into whichever of the three airports is nearest your base. Harbour Island is the exception: you get around it on foot or by golf cart.
Shopping & style
Neither island is worth visiting for shopping, but Eleuthera has a little more to browse. Dunmore Town has a few boutiques selling resortwear and linen, plus straw market stalls with woven hats, and there are a few galleries around Gregory Town. In Marathon the shops sell mostly tackle, dive gear and T-shirts along the highway.
Affordability
Both are expensive, but Eleuthera costs more. Food and fuel come in by boat, you pay for the hire car every day, and Harbour Island is priced as a luxury resort, so even a main-island cottage where you cook for yourself does not feel cheap.
Marathon is a little easier on the budget. Rentals and resorts are costly from December to April and charters add up, but summer and early autumn are cheaper if you can live with the heat and the storm risk.
Live music & performing arts
What Eleuthera has that Marathon lacks is Junkanoo. Its settlements hold a small parade on Christmas Day, and on Boxing Day and New Year's Day costumed groups with drums, cowbells and horns rush along the Dunmore Town waterfront, with visitors welcome to join the crowd. The Pineapple Festival in Gregory Town brings music and dancing in early summer, and the rest of the year you hear rake-and-scrape bands at the fish fries.
Marathon's live performance comes from a small community theatre and guitarists playing to the sunset crowd at waterfront bars, with a little more in Key West. On neither island is there a concert hall or a regular season to plan a trip around.
Wellness & relaxation
Both are good places to unwind and offer little in the way of spas. Eleuthera feels the more remote. It has fewer cars, empty beaches and nights that are dark and silent, but outside the resorts on Harbour Island and at Cape Eleuthera, a treatment means booking a therapist to come to you.
Marathon's days follow tides and sunsets. It is less remote, but the larger waterfront resorts offer massages and there are a few small day spas you can simply walk into.
When should you go?
Pick your month. The climate figures are measured averages, not a forecast.
Eleuthera in July
Marathon in July
Daytime high, °C
Rainfall in the month, mm
Where the figures come from
Eleuthera has no weather station within reach, so its figures come from a gridded climate model rather than a measured record, and read a broad area rather than one spot.
Temperature and rainfall are climate normals, averaged over the years shown. Eleuthera: 2001-2020 normals, NASA POWER reanalysis grid, no weather station within 90 km. Marathon: 2006-2020 (sunshine 1981-2010, rainfall 1991-2020) normals, Marathon / Marathon Shores (4.2 km from centre).
The two share the same rhythm: a dry, warm winter and spring, then a wet season that peaks in September. From December to April Eleuthera is the milder of the two, with highs in the low to mid twenties and little rain, while Marathon climbs from about 24°C in January to the high twenties by April. Both seas sit around 24°C in winter, cool enough to feel fresh on a breezy day but fine for swimming, and warm towards 29°C or more by late summer.
Summer is where they part. Marathon gets properly hot, around 33°C in July and August, and its wettest month brings about 180mm, against roughly 145mm on Eleuthera, which stays a few degrees cooler. Marathon's sunniest stretch runs from April to July, so late spring there combines the longest sunny days with water already warm. On both, the dry months from December to April are the easiest time to spend whole days outdoors, and from June to October the heat and storms make the days less predictable.
Which traveller are you?
On a beach and sun trip, Eleuthera is the clear choice. It offers pale-pink Atlantic strands, calm shallow coves on the western shore and Pink Sands on Harbour Island, often nearly empty. Marathon's shores are narrow and sometimes edged with seagrass.
On a family trip with children, Marathon is easier. The Turtle Hospital, the Dolphin Research Center and the children's museum at Crane Point give a family structured outings. Eleuthera has calm coves but no attractions for children and only basic medical care.
For an outdoors trip on the water, Marathon offers more. You can snorkel Sombrero Reef, fish for tarpon on the flats or for sailfish offshore, and paddle the mangroves of Curry Hammock, all from nearby marinas. Eleuthera's bonefishing and drift dives are excellent but scattered along a long island.
Before you go
| Measure | Eleuthera | Marathon |
|---|---|---|
| Official language | English | - |
| Currency | Bahamian Dollar (BSD) | US Dollar (USD) |
| Sockets | ||
| Driving side | Left | Right |
| Time zone | UTC-5, UTC-4 in summer | UTC-5, UTC-4 in summer |
| Emergency number | 919 | 911 |
| Main airport | North Eleuthera Airport (ELH)7 non-stop destinations | Miami International Airport (MIA)198 non-stop destinations |
| Public holidays this year | 11 days | 11 days |
By the numbers
| Measure | Eleuthera | Marathon |
|---|---|---|
| Population | 8,164 | 9,689 |
| People per km² | 16 | 404 |
| Swim season, months above 21 °C | 12 months | 12 months |
Where else could you go?
Every comparison below shares a destination with this one, so you can follow Eleuthera or Marathon somewhere new.
- Islamoradavs Marathon
- Key Largovs Marathon
- Evergladesvs Marathon
- Exumavs Eleuthera
- Sanibelvs Marathon
- Siesta Keyvs Marathon