VacationSelector
Vineyard rows above Cayuga Lake, Finger Lakes
Finger LakesVineyard rows above Cayuga Lake
The clay cliffs of Aquinnah from the beach, Martha's Vineyard
Martha's VineyardThe clay cliffs of Aquinnah from the beach

Photos: Finger Lakes by Andre Carrotflower, CC BY-SA 4.0, cropped; Martha's Vineyard by JP06035, CC BY-SA 3.0, cropped.

Finger Lakes or Martha's Vineyard?

Our verdict in twelve categories, each scored against the same fixed benchmark cities, and the climate month by month, so you can choose for your trip.

Choose Finger Lakes for

  • prices
  • nature and the outdoors
  • live music and the arts

The Finger Lakes suit a road trip with a loose plan: gorge walks in the morning, Riesling tastings in the afternoon and a different lake town each day. It has more to see and do than the island, from the glass museum at Corning to the waterfalls around Ithaca, and it costs much less. In return you need a car, the swimming is in a lake, and evenings end early.

Choose Martha's Vineyard for

  • beaches
  • nightlife
  • getting around

Martha's Vineyard is the better choice when the beach is the point of the trip. It has soft sand, calm Sound-side water for children and Atlantic surf on the south shore, and you can get around the down-island towns by bike, bus or on foot. It is a summer island with little beyond the shore and the townscapes, and it is one of the most expensive places in the region to spend a week in July.

Scoreboard

Twelve categories on one fixed scale from 0 to 100. The shaded stretch is the gap between the two.

Beaches & swimming. Finger Lakes 45, Martha's Vineyard 68: Martha's Vineyard leads by 23 points.
Food & drink. Finger Lakes 52, Martha's Vineyard 45: Finger Lakes leads by 7 points.
Culture & sights. Finger Lakes 45, Martha's Vineyard 35: Finger Lakes leads by 10 points.
Nightlife. Finger Lakes 18, Martha's Vineyard 22: Martha's Vineyard leads by 4 points.
Nature & outdoors. Finger Lakes 68, Martha's Vineyard 50: Finger Lakes leads by 18 points.
Day trips. Finger Lakes 58, Martha's Vineyard 44: Finger Lakes leads by 14 points.
Good for families. Finger Lakes and Martha's Vineyard are level on 56.
Getting around. Finger Lakes 45, Martha's Vineyard 48: Martha's Vineyard leads by 3 points.
Shopping & style. Finger Lakes 30, Martha's Vineyard 32: Martha's Vineyard leads by 2 points.
Affordability. Finger Lakes 42, Martha's Vineyard 10: Finger Lakes leads by 32 points.
Live music & performing arts. Finger Lakes 40, Martha's Vineyard 22: Finger Lakes leads by 18 points.
Wellness & relaxation. Finger Lakes 42, Martha's Vineyard 45: Martha's Vineyard leads by 3 points.
0255075100

Your match

Pick a travel style or drag the sliders, and both match scores follow your weighting.

Finger Lakes
Best match
45match

Wins on prices and nature and the outdoors with your weighting.

Martha's Vineyard
40match

Wins on beaches and nightlife with your weighting.

What matters to you?

Category by category

What the scores mean for a trip.

Beaches & swimming

Martha's Vineyard 68Finger Lakes 45

This is the island's clearest advantage. Martha's Vineyard has real sea beaches on two very different shores: calm, shallow water along State Beach on the Sound side, open Atlantic waves at Katama's South Beach and striking sand under the cliffs at Aquinnah and Menemsha. The sand is soft and there is plenty of it, although some of the best up-island beaches are kept for residents in summer.

The Finger Lakes offer freshwater swimming from shingle or coarse-sand strands in state parks, such as Taughannock Point or Kershaw Park, and from rented docks. The water is no colder than the island's in August, and the pools beneath the waterfalls near Ithaca are memorable when they open. Still, nobody chooses the lakes for a beach.

Food & drink

Finger Lakes 52Martha's Vineyard 45

The Finger Lakes have the richer table, and it is built around wine. Tasting rooms above Seneca, Keuka and Cayuga sell some of the best Riesling in North America, alongside cider and farm-to-table cooking. Ithaca's farmers' market and its vegetarian tradition give the region some depth beyond the vineyards.

Martha's Vineyard does one thing very well: plain New England seafood, at its best eaten as steamed lobster on the docks at Menemsha. Beyond that the restaurants are few, expensive and mostly closed out of season. In some up-island towns you bring your own bottle to dinner.

Culture & sights

Finger Lakes 45Martha's Vineyard 35

The Finger Lakes have more substance to visit. The Corning Museum of Glass is world class, and Seneca Falls and Auburn hold key sites of women's rights and abolitionist history. Rochester's George Eastman Museum is within reach, although the sites are spread out and you need to drive between them.

The island's heritage is something you walk through rather than look at in a museum. It has Edgartown's whaling captains' houses, the gingerbread cottages around the Oak Bluffs tabernacle, the Flying Horses Carousel and the African American heritage trail. These fill two or three easy days, but there is no major collection.

Nightlife

Martha's Vineyard 22Finger Lakes 18

Neither is a place for a night out, and both wind down early. The difference is in what is open. On the island, summer evenings gather in a few bars on Circuit Avenue in Oak Bluffs and around Edgartown harbour, among visitors and seasonal staff, and outside July and August there is almost nothing. Around the lakes the only real crowd is students, in Ithaca's Collegetown bars in term time, and otherwise the evening is a brewpub or a drink on the dock.

Nature & outdoors

Finger Lakes 68Martha's Vineyard 50

The Finger Lakes have the more dramatic scenery. Glaciers cut gorges through the shale, and there are nineteen waterfalls at Watkins Glen, Taughannock and Buttermilk Falls near Ithaca, and Letchworth's deep canyon on the western edge. Between them, vineyards and national forest make good country for hiking, cycling and paddling, with strong autumn colour.

Martha's Vineyard is lower and softer, with moors, salt ponds, stone walls and the coloured cliffs of Aquinnah. It suits an unhurried bike ride, birdwatching at Felix Neck or surfcasting off Cape Poge, but nothing on the island matches the drama of the lake gorges or the canyon at Letchworth.

Day trips

Finger Lakes 58Martha's Vineyard 44

From the Finger Lakes the choice is wider and lasts all year. Each lake has its own town and wine trail, from Skaneateles to Hammondsport, and Niagara Falls is under two hours' drive from Canandaigua. All of it needs a car.

The island's best outings go by sea: Nantucket's whaling town, New Bedford's historic district or the villages of Cape Cod via Woods Hole. They make good days out, but most of the ferries run only from late spring to early autumn, so out of season you are mostly limited to the island's own towns.

Good for families

Finger Lakes 56Martha's Vineyard 56

Both suit families in summer, but in different ways. Martha's Vineyard is the simple beach vacation, with shallow Sound-side water, cycle paths between towns, the carousel and crabbing off the docks. It has little to fall back on in a spell of wet weather.

The Finger Lakes give children more to do: the Strong National Museum of Play and the zoo in Rochester, the Sciencenter in Ithaca, making a glass piece at Corning and the gorge trails. The cost is long hours in the car.

Getting around

Martha's Vineyard 48Finger Lakes 45

In the Finger Lakes you depend on a car from arrival to departure. The drives along the lake shores are a pleasure, but there is no regional rail and the buses between towns are sparse.

Martha's Vineyard works the other way round. The effort comes at the start, with the ferry crossing, and after that you can manage without a car, getting around the down-island towns on foot, by bike or on the island bus. The catch is the up-island roads, which clog in high summer.

Shopping & style

Martha's Vineyard 32Finger Lakes 30

Shopping is a sideline on both, and what you bring home is quite different. From the lakes it is cases of Riesling, studio glass from Corning's Gaslight District, books from the Ithaca Commons and antiques from roadside shops. From the island it is preppy clothes and gallery art from Edgartown, or island-branded clothing and local pottery from the Chilmark flea market, with many shops shut out of season.

Affordability

Finger Lakes 42Martha's Vineyard 10

The Finger Lakes are far easier on the wallet. Summer weekends at lakeside inns are not cheap, but town motels, state park cabins and campsites, inexpensive gorge parks and farm stands give you real ways to spend less, and weekdays cost noticeably less again.

Martha's Vineyard is expensive across the board in summer. Rentals are booked by the week months ahead, eating out is costly even at the shacks, and the ferry adds more, especially if you bring a car. Bikes, buses and picnics help a little, but late spring or autumn is the only real saving.

Live music & performing arts

Finger Lakes 40Martha's Vineyard 22

The Finger Lakes have much more going on, mostly because of Rochester at the northern edge. There you have the Eastman School's concert halls, a full philharmonic season and a large jazz festival every June. Closer to the lakes there are the GrassRoots festival in Trumansburg, summer playhouses in Ithaca and Auburn, and Geneva's Smith Opera House.

On the island the programme is short and local: concerts and sing-alongs in the Oak Bluffs Tabernacle, a small playhouse in Vineyard Haven and bands in summer bars.

Wellness & relaxation

Martha's Vineyard 45Finger Lakes 42

Neither has a bathing tradition, and both offer only a few inn spas, so on both the calm comes from the pace. Around the lakes it means porch afternoons over the water, early canoe mornings and the retreat centres near Ithaca. On the island it means the up-island farm roads around Chilmark and West Tisbury, at their quietest around September, away from the summer crowds in Edgartown.

When should you go?

Pick your month. The climate figures are measured averages, not a forecast.

Finger Lakes in July

28 °Cdaytime high
18 °Cnight-time low
87 mmrain in the month
10 hsunshine a day
21 °Csea
15 hdaylight a day

Martha's Vineyard in July

26 °Cdaytime high
18 °Cnight-time low
73 mmrain in the month
10 hsunshine a day
20 °Csea
15 hdaylight a day

Daytime high, °C

0°10°20°30°JFMAMJJASOND

Rainfall in the month, mm

0255075100125JFMAMJJASOND
Finger LakesMartha's Vineyard

Where the figures come from

Finger Lakes's temperatures are measured 27 km from the centre, at Penn Yan.

Finger Lakes's station stands 163 m above the place it is measured for, so that place is likely a little warmer than the figures say.

Finger Lakes has no rain gauge within 25 km of the centre, so its rainfall comes from a gridded climate dataset read at the destination rather than from a gauge further away.

Finger Lakes's sunshine is measured 63 km from the centre, at Greater Rochester International.

Martha's Vineyard has no rain gauge within 25 km of the centre, so its rainfall comes from a gridded climate dataset read at the destination rather than from a gauge further away.

Martha's Vineyard's sunshine is measured 86 km from the centre, at Providence Green State Airport.

Temperature and rainfall are climate normals, averaged over the years shown. Finger Lakes: 2006-2020 (sunshine 1981-2010, rainfall 1991-2020) normals, Penn Yan (26.6 km from centre). Martha's Vineyard: 2006-2020 (sunshine 1981-2010, rainfall 1991-2020) normals, Marthas Vineyard / Tississa (8.4 km from centre).

Both have a short swimming season, from July into early September, and the water is cold either side of it. Around the lakes summer is a little hotter, with highs of about 28°C in July, and the larger lakes reach about 22°C in August. They stay a touch warmer than the island's sea into September. Winter is properly cold, with January highs around 1°C. Late spring and early autumn are the best months for walking, and October brings the colour to the gorges and vineyards.

On Martha's Vineyard the sea evens out the year. Summers are slightly cooler, winters milder, and from autumn to early spring the island gets more sunshine than the lakes. The rain falls the other way round. The island is wettest from October to December, at about 120mm a month, and driest in July at around 73mm, while around the lakes the wettest months are in summer. September is warm and pleasant on both, and that is the month to choose if you want to swim and still avoid the peak of summer.

Which traveller are you?

On a beach and sun trip, Martha's Vineyard wins easily. It has long stretches of soft sand, sheltered and shallow water along State Beach, surf at South Beach and the clay cliffs at Aquinnah. The Finger Lakes offer small lakeside strands and dock swimming, which is pleasant but not really a beach vacation.

For an outdoors trip, the Finger Lakes have more variety. You can walk the stone-stepped gorge trail at Watkins Glen, swim under the falls near Ithaca, spend a day in the canyon at Letchworth and cycle long loops round the lakes. The island's moors, ponds and bike paths are gentler and smaller in scale.

On a trip on a tight budget, the Finger Lakes are the only realistic choice of the two. Campsites, cabins, town motels and farm stands keep costs down, especially on weekdays. On the island, summer lodging, the ferry and even the seafood shacks are expensive, and there is no cheap way round them.

Before you go

MeasureFinger LakesMartha's Vineyard
CurrencyUS Dollar (USD)US Dollar (USD)
SocketsAB120 V, 60 HzAB120 V, 60 Hz
Driving sideRightRight
Time zoneUTC-5, UTC-4 in summerUTC-5, UTC-4 in summer
Emergency number911911
Main airportFrederick Douglass Greater Rochester International Airport (ROC)25 non-stop destinationsBoston Logan International Airport (BOS)144 non-stop destinations
Public holidays this year13 days12 days

By the numbers

MeasureFinger LakesMartha's Vineyard
Population-14,729
People per km²-65
Swim season, months above 21 °C1 monthNone

Where else could you go?

Every comparison below shares a destination with this one, so you can follow Finger Lakes or Martha's Vineyard somewhere new.

Browse every destination

Sources

Ground elevations sampled from the Mapzen terrain tiles via OpenTopoData, merging SRTM, ASTER, NED, EU-DEM and national sources. Structured data from Wikidata (CC0). Weather data by Meteostat. Meteorological data provided by NOAA, DWD and others. Rainfall where no rain gauge is within 25 km is from the TerraClimate 1991-2020 climatology (Abatzoglou et al. 2018, Scientific Data), read at the city. Sea surface temperature from NOAA OISST v2.1, NOAA Physical Sciences Laboratory. Airport data from OurAirports (public domain). Public holidays from Nager.Date (MIT). Exchange rates via Frankfurter, based on European Central Bank reference rates. Non-stop route lists from the "Airlines and destinations" tables on English Wikipedia airport articles, by Wikipedia contributors, reused under CC BY-SA 4.0. Currency from the ISO 4217 register maintained by SIX, cross-checked against country data from GeoNames (CC BY 4.0). Price level from World Bank open data (PPP conversion factor for private consumption and official exchange rate), CC BY 4.0. Time zones from GeoNames (CC BY 4.0); clock offsets computed from the IANA time zone database. Daylight hours computed from each destination's latitude using the NOAA solar position algorithm.

Category scores are our editorial verdict under rubric v3, each placed against the same fixed benchmark cities; the climate figures are measured. How the scores are set. Snapshot generated 2026-11-17. Daily budgets are estimates from country price levels.