

Photos: Finger Lakes by Andre Carrotflower, CC BY-SA 4.0, cropped; Nantucket by Jeff Dell, CC BY 2.0, cropped.
Finger Lakes or Nantucket?
Our verdict in twelve categories, each scored against the same fixed benchmark cities, and the climate month by month, so you can choose for your trip.
Choose Finger Lakes for
- prices
- day trips
- nature and the outdoors
The Finger Lakes suit a driving trip through wine country and gorge country. Over a week you can move between lakes, taste Riesling on the slopes above Seneca and Keuka, walk the waterfall trails at Watkins Glen and around Ithaca, and spend far less than an island summer would cost. What you give up is a proper sea beach and the ease of a vacation without a car.
Choose Nantucket for
- beaches
- getting around
- shopping
Choose Nantucket for a settled beach vacation where the car stays at home. Days run from a bike ride along the paved paths to the sand at Surfside or the calm water at Jetties, then dinner in a preserved whaling town. It is steeply priced, and once you are there the island is most of what you will see.
Scoreboard
Twelve categories on one fixed scale from 0 to 100. The shaded stretch is the gap between the two.
Your match
Pick a travel style or drag the sliders, and both match scores follow your weighting.
Wins on prices and day trips with your weighting.
Wins on beaches and getting around with your weighting.
What matters to you?
Category by category
What the scores mean for a trip.
Beaches & swimming
The Finger Lakes swim in fresh water, from docks and small state park strands such as Taughannock Point and Kershaw Park, on shingle or coarse sand with no waves. The waterfall pools near Ithaca, open in some summers, are a swim the island cannot match. Even so, this is lake life rather than a beach vacation.
Nantucket is the beach destination of the two. Within a short bike ride it has sheltered, shallow water on the sound side near town and long open Atlantic sand with real surf on the south shore at Surfside, Cisco and Madaket, where people also go for the sunset.
Food & drink
Both eat best in late summer, but in different ways. The Finger Lakes are wine country, with Riesling, Cabernet Franc and sparkling wine poured in tasting rooms above the lakes and farm-to-table cooking in winery restaurants. The widest choice is in Ithaca, with its vegetarian tradition and farmers' market on the inlet.
Nantucket is about the sea: oysters, autumn bay scallops, striped bass and lobster, served at clam shacks by the harbour or in polished dining rooms in old town houses. Its kitchens are ambitious for an island this size, but the range is narrow, and in both places choice thins out of season.
Culture & sights
The two are evenly matched but set out very differently. The Finger Lakes' heritage is spread across the region: the Corning Museum of Glass, the Women's Rights National Historical Park at Seneca Falls, Harriet Tubman's home in Auburn and the Eastman photography museum in Rochester. Each takes a few hours, with drives in between.
On Nantucket the culture is the town itself, an intact whaling port of cobbled streets and captains' houses. The Whaling Museum is the centrepiece, with Sconset's cottages and the lighthouses beyond. Two days on foot covers it, while the lakes reward a longer stay with a car.
Nightlife
In the Finger Lakes the wineries shut in the late afternoon, and evenings mean a brewpub or a drink on a dock, with only Ithaca's term-time college bars showing much life. Nantucket has a little more going on in July and August, when the harbour pubs and Main Street bars fill up and a dance bar out of town has live bands, though it still closes early.
Nature & outdoors
The Finger Lakes have the more striking landscape. Long glacial lakes sit beside shale gorges, with waterfall trails at Watkins Glen, Taughannock and Robert H. Treman, Letchworth's canyon on the western edge and national forest for gentle hiking. The autumn colour peaks in October.
Nantucket is flat and gentle. Its appeal is protected heathland, cranberry bogs and ponds best seen by bike, plus seals and shorebirds at Great Point and Coatue. It suits easy days outdoors, but there are no hills and the walks are short.
Day trips
From a Finger Lakes base each day can be a different lake with its own town and wine trail, from polished Skaneateles to Hammondsport among the old vineyards. Niagara Falls is under two hours from Canandaigua, though all of it needs a car.
Nantucket sits 50km out to sea, so the options beyond the island are Martha's Vineyard by the summer ferry or Cape Cod via Hyannis, and both make long days once the crossing is counted. Most visitors simply stay put.
Good for families
Both work for a summer with children, in different ways. The Finger Lakes have more that is built for children, from Rochester's Strong National Museum of Play and zoo to Ithaca's Sciencenter and making glass at Corning, and the gorge trails thrill older children. The cost is long spells in the car.
Nantucket is simpler: calm water with lifeguards at Children's Beach, flat bike paths away from traffic, and a small, safe town where older children can roam. It lacks large attractions, the south shore surf is too rough for little ones, and family rooms are expensive.
Getting around
The Finger Lakes are easy to reach but impossible to see without a car, since there is no regional rail and buses between towns are sparse. The lakeside roads are a pleasure to drive, but going round the ends of the lakes adds time, and wine tasters often hire a driver.
Nantucket is far easier once you arrive. The town is walkable, paved bike paths run to the beaches and villages, and a summer shuttle bus fills the gaps, so nobody needs a car. The effort is the ferry or flight to get there.
Shopping & style
Shopping in the Finger Lakes mostly means cases of wine, farm produce and roadside antiques. The highlights are the studio glass in Corning's Gaslight District and the bookshops on the Ithaca Commons.
Nantucket has more to browse. Main Street has boutiques, galleries, jewellers and interiors shops, and the island has its own crafts in lightship baskets and scrimshaw. It is still small and aimed at well-off summer visitors.
Affordability
Neither is cheap in high season, but the Finger Lakes cost far less. Lakeside inns fill up and charge accordingly on summer and autumn weekends. Even so, chain motels, state park cabins and campsites, inexpensive gorge parks and farm stands keep a trip within reach, especially on weekdays.
Nantucket is among the most expensive summer destinations in the country. Rooms and rental houses cost more than in big cities, and meals carry island prices. The beaches and bike paths cost little and June and September are easier on the bill, but nothing there is cheap.
Live music & performing arts
The Finger Lakes offer more, much of it in Rochester at the northern edge: the Eastman School of Music, the Rochester Philharmonic and a large jazz festival each June. Nearer the lakes there are Ithaca's historic theatre, Geneva's Smith Opera House, summer musicals in Auburn and the GrassRoots festival in Trumansburg.
Nantucket's programme is small and seasonal. It has two theatre companies, chamber concerts at the Atheneum, and a June film festival that is the one event people travel for.
Wellness & relaxation
Neither has a bathing tradition, and both have only a few hotel and inn spas, so in each the appeal is the pace rather than the treatments. In the Finger Lakes that means lake-view resort pools at Skaneateles or Canandaigua, early mornings in a canoe and retreat centres around Ithaca. On Nantucket it is the rhythm of bike, beach and dinner on an island without traffic lights.
When should you go?
Pick your month. The climate figures are measured averages, not a forecast.
Finger Lakes in July
Nantucket in July
Daytime high, °C
Rainfall in the month, mm
Where the figures come from
Finger Lakes's temperatures are measured 27 km from the centre, at Penn Yan.
Finger Lakes's station stands 163 m above the place it is measured for, so that place is likely a little warmer than the figures say.
Finger Lakes has no rain gauge within 25 km of the centre, so its rainfall comes from a gridded climate dataset read at the destination rather than from a gauge further away.
Finger Lakes's sunshine is measured 63 km from the centre, at Greater Rochester International.
Nantucket's temperatures are measured 44 km from the centre, at Chatham.
Nantucket has no rain gauge within 25 km of the centre, so its rainfall comes from a gridded climate dataset read at the destination rather than from a gauge further away.
Temperature and rainfall are climate normals, averaged over the years shown. Finger Lakes: 2006-2020 (sunshine 1981-2010, rainfall 1991-2020) normals, Penn Yan (26.6 km from centre). Nantucket: 1991-2020 normals, Chatham (44 km from centre).
Both are summer destinations with short swimming seasons. Around the Finger Lakes, July is the warmest month at about 28°C and the lakes reach around 22°C by August, so late June to early September is the time to swim. Summer is also the wettest part of the year. June is the rainiest month at about 92mm, with July and August close behind, though these are also the sunniest months, so the showers and storms fall between long bright days. September and October stay mild for the gorges and wine trails. From December to March the region is cold and snowy, with daytime highs barely above freezing.
Nantucket has a cooler summer, peaking at about 24°C in July and August. That is comfortable for cycling and walking the town but rarely hot. The sea reaches only about 20°C in August, so swimming is best from July onwards and June is bracing. The island's rain follows the opposite pattern to the lakes: July is its driest month, and the rain builds through autumn into a grey, damp winter that is still milder than the frozen months inland.
Which traveller are you?
On a beach and sun trip, Nantucket is the clear choice. You can leave the car at home, cycle to the sand each morning and pick between gentle water for paddling and proper surf. In the Finger Lakes the swimming is off a dock, so it is not really a beach vacation.
On a trip on a tight budget, the Finger Lakes are far easier to manage. A week spent driving between lakes, with picnics, free walks and simple rooms in the towns rather than on the water, costs a fraction of the island. On Nantucket even a short summer stay strains a small budget.
For an outdoors trip, the Finger Lakes give an active traveller more variety. You might spend a morning on a waterfall trail and an afternoon paddling or cycling along a lakeshore, with a new landscape each day. Nantucket's outdoors is gentle, with flat rides and short walks that fill a day or two.
Before you go
| Measure | Finger Lakes | Nantucket |
|---|---|---|
| Currency | US Dollar (USD) | US Dollar (USD) |
| Sockets | ||
| Driving side | Right | Right |
| Time zone | UTC-5, UTC-4 in summer | UTC-5, UTC-4 in summer |
| Emergency number | 911 | 911 |
| Main airport | Frederick Douglass Greater Rochester International Airport (ROC)25 non-stop destinations | Nantucket Memorial Airport (ACK)12 non-stop destinations |
| Public holidays this year | 13 days | 12 days |
By the numbers
| Measure | Finger Lakes | Nantucket |
|---|---|---|
| Population | - | 14,255 |
| People per km² | - | 115 |
| Swim season, months above 21 °C | 1 month | None |
Where else could you go?
Every comparison below shares a destination with this one, so you can follow Finger Lakes or Nantucket somewhere new.
- Martha's Vineyardvs Nantucket
- Cape Codvs Nantucket
- Niagara Fallsvs Finger Lakes
- The Hamptonsvs Nantucket
- Catskillsvs Finger Lakes
- Poconosvs Finger Lakes