

Photos: Hudson Valley by Brett A, Pexels License; Nantucket by Jeff Dell, CC BY 2.0, cropped.
Hudson Valley or Nantucket?
Our verdict in twelve categories, each scored against the same fixed benchmark cities, and the climate month by month, so you can choose for your trip.
Choose Hudson Valley for
- day trips
- nature and the outdoors
- prices
The Hudson Valley is the better choice if you want a varied trip on the move. You can scramble up Breakneck Ridge in the morning and spend the afternoon among the Hyde Park estates or the steel sculptures at Storm King, then have dinner from the farms around Hudson or Rhinebeck. Manhattan is close enough for a day by train. You will need a car for most of it, it is at its best in autumn, and while it isn't cheap, it costs far less than the island.
Choose Nantucket for
- beaches
- getting around
- nightlife
Nantucket is for a summer beach trip spent in one small place. You can leave the car on the mainland, cycle to Jetties or Surfside, and walk the cobbled whaling town after dark. In return you give up variety: the landscape is flat, there is little to do beyond the island, the season is short, and the cost in July and August is very high.
Scoreboard
Twelve categories on one fixed scale from 0 to 100. The shaded stretch is the gap between the two.
Your match
Pick a travel style or drag the sliders, and both match scores follow your weighting.
Wins on day trips and nature and the outdoors with your weighting.
Wins on beaches and getting around with your weighting.
What matters to you?
Category by category
What the scores mean for a trip.
Beaches & swimming
This is where Nantucket clearly wins. It is surrounded by real sea beaches: the calm, warmer sound side at Jetties and Children's Beach, and the long open Atlantic sands of Surfside, Cisco and Madaket, where the waves are big enough to play in. You can plan a whole summer stay around them.
The Hudson Valley has no coast. Swimming there means a lake beach at Harriman or Lake Taghkanic, a stream pool in the Catskills, or one of the few supervised river spots such as Croton Point. These are pleasant on a hot afternoon, but they aren't a reason to go.
Food & drink
The Hudson Valley has more depth. In Hudson, Rhinebeck, Kingston and Beacon, the restaurants cook with produce from nearby farms and orchards. The Culinary Institute at Hyde Park lets visitors eat in its student restaurants. Cideries, distilleries and the Shawangunk wineries add plenty to drink.
Nantucket's cooking is narrower but very good in its own way. It is built on the sea, with oysters, autumn bay scallops, striped bass and lobster, served at harbour clam shacks or in polished dining rooms in old houses. Outside summer, many of its kitchens close.
Culture & sights
The Hudson Valley offers far more to see. It has Roosevelt's home and library at Hyde Park, the Vanderbilt Mansion, Kykuit and Sunnyside, and Olana with the Hudson River School painters. On top of that come two major modern art sites, Dia Beacon and Storm King. Everything is spread along the river, so you pick a few sights a day and drive between them.
Nantucket's history is concentrated in one place: an intact whaling seaport of captains' houses and cobbled lanes, with the Whaling Museum and its sperm whale skeleton at the centre. It is lovely to walk, but two days covers it.
Nightlife
Neither place suits a big night out, and both centre their evenings on dinner and a drink. The Hudson Valley's bars open all year: taprooms and wine bars in Kingston, Beacon and Hudson, plus student bars in New Paltz and Poughkeepsie. Nantucket's harbour pubs and its single live-band dance bar are lively in July and August, then go quiet soon after dinner for the rest of the year.
Nature & outdoors
The Hudson Valley's landscape is much more dramatic and varied. The river cuts a fjord-like gorge through the Highlands, the Shawangunk cliffs are among the best-known climbing areas in North America, and the Catskill escarpment offers Kaaterskill Falls and long ridge walks. Autumn colour across the hardwood forests is the high point of the year.
Nantucket's outdoors is gentle and low-lying. You cycle the paved paths across heath and cranberry bogs, sail or kayak in the harbour, cast for bluefish, or ride out to Great Point to see grey seals. It is restful, but you won't find a hill to climb.
Day trips
An hour on Metro-North from the lower valley, or about two from Poughkeepsie, gets you to Manhattan's museums and streets, so a city day fits easily into a country stay. Closer to base, the river towns each fill a half-day, from Cold Spring's antique shops to Woodstock's artists' colony and Kingston's stone quarter. From the northern end, Albany, Saratoga Springs and the Berkshire towns of Stockbridge and Lenox are all within a drive.
Nantucket's position 50km out to sea makes it a place to stay put rather than a base for exploring. In summer the inter-island ferry to Oak Bluffs and Edgartown on Martha's Vineyard is the one obvious outing. Cape Cod is about an hour away by fast ferry, but with the crossings both ways it makes for a long day.
Good for families
Both work well with children, but they suit different families. The Hudson Valley suits families happy to drive. There are pick-your-own orchards and pumpkin patches, Legoland near Goshen, and the bear and deer carousel at Bear Mountain, though the long drives and steep trails can wear young children out.
Nantucket keeps things simple and close together. Lifeguarded calm water at Children's Beach, flat car-free bike paths and a small, safe town give older children some freedom. The south shore surf is too rough for little swimmers, and family-sized rooms book up far ahead.
Getting around
Nantucket is far easier once you are there. The town is walkable, paved bike paths reach Sconset, Madaket and the south shore beaches, and a summer shuttle bus covers the rest, so most visitors rent bikes and never miss a car. The effort comes in reaching it, by ferry from Hyannis or a short flight.
The Hudson Valley's riverside railway makes a car-free weekend possible in Beacon, Cold Spring or Hudson. To see the mansions, art parks, trailheads and west-bank towns, though, you need a car, and autumn weekends bring traffic and full parking at trailheads.
Shopping & style
Both offer pleasant browsing rather than serious shopping, and neither has department stores. The Hudson Valley is about antiques and interiors, along Hudson's Warren Street and in smaller towns such as Saugerties. It also has Woodstock pottery, farm-stand preserves and the big outlet village near Central Valley. Nantucket is preppier and more compact: Main Street clothing boutiques and galleries, plus woven lightship baskets and scrimshaw as the island's own crafts.
Affordability
Neither is cheap, but the Hudson Valley is much easier on the wallet. Inns in Rhinebeck or Hudson charge high prices on foliage weekends, but chain motels around Newburgh or Kingston, midweek stays and diner meals bring costs down. Hiking and the state parks cost little or nothing.
Nantucket in July and August is among the most expensive summer trips in the United States. Rooms, rental houses and meals all carry island prices, and bringing a car over adds more. June and September cost less, but no part of the island is cheap.
Live music & performing arts
The Hudson Valley can fill several summer evenings with work that people drive up from the city to see, led by opera and dance at Bard's Fisher Center and open-air Shakespeare above the river at Garrison, with Tanglewood also within a drive. Once summer ends the programme gets thinner but keeps going, through a few restored theatres and the roots and rock rooms of Kingston and Woodstock.
Nantucket's stage is the size of a small town, and it only really runs in summer: a local play, a concert in a church or the old library, a band in a harbour bar. The June film festival is the exception, and worth planning around if films matter to you. At any other time of year, an evening out on the island means dinner rather than a show.
Wellness & relaxation
The Hudson Valley gives you more ways to unwind. Grand Victorian lake resorts with full spas sit on the Shawangunk Ridge, retreat centres around Rhinebeck run yoga weekends, and Buddhist monasteries near Carmel and Mount Tremper welcome visitors to meditate.
Nantucket's calm comes from the island itself rather than from treatments. There are no traffic lights, and the days follow a bike-beach-dinner rhythm. Beyond that, there are only a few hotel and day spas in town.
When should you go?
Pick your month. The climate figures are measured averages, not a forecast.
Hudson Valley in July
Nantucket in July
Daytime high, °C
Rainfall in the month, mm
Where the figures come from
Hudson Valley's temperatures are measured 35 km from the centre, at Poughkeepsie / New Hackensack.
Hudson Valley has no rain gauge within 25 km of the centre, so its rainfall comes from a gridded climate dataset read at the destination rather than from a gauge further away.
Nantucket's temperatures are measured 44 km from the centre, at Chatham.
Nantucket has no rain gauge within 25 km of the centre, so its rainfall comes from a gridded climate dataset read at the destination rather than from a gauge further away.
Temperature and rainfall are climate normals, averaged over the years shown. Hudson Valley: 1991-2020 normals, Poughkeepsie / New Hackensack (34.5 km from centre). Nantucket: 1991-2020 normals, Chatham (44 km from centre).
The Hudson Valley has hot summers, with July around 30°C. That suits lake swimming and long evenings but can be heavy for steep hikes. June and September are better for walking, and October brings the autumn colour. October is also one of the wettest months, because rain falls fairly evenly all year with no dry season. Winters are cold and grey, with January highs near 2°C, so most visits run from May to October.
Around Nantucket Town, summer is milder. July and August peak at about 24°C, which makes cycling and walking easy. The sea only becomes comfortable in high summer, reaching about 20°C in August, and in June it is still cold. July is the island's driest month. From late autumn the island turns wet and windy, and December is the wettest month at 126mm, so outside summer it is a quiet place for walks rather than a beach destination.
Which traveller are you?
On a beach and sun trip, choose Nantucket. Calm, shallow water at Jetties and Children's Beach, real surf at Surfside and Cisco, and sunsets at Madaket are all a short bike ride apart. The Hudson Valley only has lakes and stream pools.
For an outdoors trip, choose the Hudson Valley. You get the steep Highlands gorge, the Appalachian Trail across Bear Mountain, Shawangunk climbing cliffs and Catskill waterfalls. Nantucket's flat moors and seal trips to Great Point are pleasant but much gentler.
On a trip on a tight budget, the Hudson Valley is the realistic option. Chain motels around Poughkeepsie or Kingston, midweek stays, diners and free state parks keep costs down. Nantucket is expensive everywhere on the island, even in June and September.
Before you go
| Measure | Hudson Valley | Nantucket |
|---|---|---|
| Currency | US Dollar (USD) | US Dollar (USD) |
| Sockets | ||
| Driving side | Right | Right |
| Time zone | UTC-5, UTC-4 in summer | UTC-5, UTC-4 in summer |
| Emergency number | 911 | 911 |
| Main airport | New York Stewart International Airport (SWF)9 non-stop destinations | Nantucket Memorial Airport (ACK)12 non-stop destinations |
| Public holidays this year | 13 days | 12 days |
By the numbers
| Measure | Hudson Valley | Nantucket |
|---|---|---|
| Population | - | 14,255 |
| People per km² | - | 115 |
| Swim season, months above 21 °C | - | None |
Where else could you go?
Every comparison below shares a destination with this one, so you can follow Hudson Valley or Nantucket somewhere new.
- Catskillsvs Hudson Valley
- Martha's Vineyardvs Nantucket
- Cape Codvs Nantucket
- Poconosvs Hudson Valley
- The Hamptonsvs Nantucket
- The Hamptonsvs Hudson Valley