

Photos: Isles of Scilly by Mark Percy, CC BY-SA 2.0, cropped; Peak District by Donnchadh H, CC BY 2.0, cropped.
Isles of Scilly or Peak District?
Our verdict in twelve categories, each scored against the same fixed benchmark cities, and the climate month by month, so you can choose for your trip.
Choose Isles of Scilly for
- beaches
- getting around
The Isles of Scilly suit travellers who want a slow, sea-bound week of pale sand, clear water and boat trips between small islands, and who don't mind a high bill to get it. Choose them for empty beaches, seals and puffins, and a place where there are no cars and the tide sets the timetable. Shops, live performances and anything beyond the five inhabited islands are scarce.
Choose Peak District for
- day trips
- live music and the arts
- prices
For walkers, families and anyone who wants more to see and do, the Peak District is the stronger choice. It has open moorland and limestone dales, great houses such as Chatsworth, Buxton's opera house and spa, and big cities within reach for a day out, and all of it costs noticeably less. What it can't offer is a beach, and away from the railway lines you will want a car.
Scoreboard
Twelve categories on one fixed scale from 0 to 100. The shaded stretch is the gap between the two.
Your match
Pick a travel style or drag the sliders, and both match scores follow your weighting.
Wins on beaches and getting around with your weighting.
Wins on day trips and live music and the arts with your weighting.
What matters to you?
Category by category
What the scores mean for a trip.
Beaches & swimming
This is Scilly's clearest advantage. Its pale sand bays are sheltered and the water is clear, from the long sweeps of Par Beach on St Martin's to the sandbar at Pelistry on St Mary's, and they stay quiet even in August. The catch is an Atlantic that stays cool all summer, so swims are short.
The Peak District is landlocked, and its cold reservoirs are not for swimming. The best you will find is the heated outdoor pool at Hathersage or a dip in a river in the dales, so beach lovers have only one choice here.
Food & drink
Neither is a place to travel for food, but the Peak District has a little more choice. It has stone pubs serving local ale, Bakewell pudding, Hartington cheese, the Chatsworth farm shops and a few ambitious country-house dining rooms, spread over a wide area.
On Scilly, the best of the eating is simple seafood: crab and lobster from local boats, eaten on a café terrace above a beach, plus eggs and fudge from roadside honesty stalls. Most restaurants are in Hugh Town, many visitors cook for themselves, and choice drops off sharply outside the main season.
Culture & sights
Scilly's history is small in scale and bound up with the sea. It includes the Garrison walls around Star Castle above Hugh Town, the Bronze Age entrance graves at Innisidgen and Porth Hellick, and Cromwell's Castle guarding New Grimsby Sound on Tresco. At Tresco Abbey Garden, the Valhalla collection holds figureheads from ships wrecked on the rocks. Taking it in means walking and catching boats, and two or three days is enough.
The Peak District has more to see, and on a much grander scale. Chatsworth is among England's finest country houses and Haddon Hall is a rare intact medieval one. Georgian Buxton, the plague village of Eyam and Arkwright's mills at Cromford add variety. Together they make a rich day or two, but the sights are spread across the park, so plan on driving between them.
Nightlife
Both are early-to-bed places with no clubs, so the difference lies in what an evening looks like. In the Peak District, it means a village pub with a fire and a room of walkers. Buxton and Matlock have a few later bars, and Sheffield or Manchester are about an hour away for a real night out.
On Scilly, a summer evening means watching the pilot gig crews race in the harbour and having a pint on the quay. If you are staying on an off-island, the last boat back also ends the night.
Nature & outdoors
For walking and outdoor activity, the Peak District offers more. Gritstone moors such as Kinder Scout contrast with the green limestone dales of Dovedale and Lathkill. There are climbing edges at Stanage and Curbar, the start of the Pennine Way, traffic-free cycling trails and caves to explore.
Scilly's strength is wildlife and the sea rather than hills. Boats take you out to grey seals and nesting puffins, birdwatchers arrive in October for rare migrants, and you can snorkel or kayak in the sheltered channels. Its coastal walks, such as around Hell Bay on Bryher, are wild but short, a few hours for each island.
Day trips
The Peak District's position in the middle of England makes it an easy base for days out. Manchester and Sheffield are a short train ride away, and Hardwick Hall, Bolsover Castle and Kedleston Hall sit just outside the park. With a longer drive, you can reach the Potteries, Chester or York.
On Scilly, a day out means taking a boat to another island: well-kept Tresco, wild Bryher, quiet St Martin's or remote St Agnes. Each is enjoyable, but there is nothing beyond them, since the Cornish mainland is too far for a comfortable return trip in a day.
Good for families
For families, the Peak District has more to fill the days. There are show caves at Castleton and Buxton, the cable car up to the Heights of Abraham, vintage trams at Crich, Chatsworth's farmyard and adventure playground, and Alton Towers a short drive away. The flat railway trails are ideal for cycling with children. You will need a car, though.
Scilly offers a different kind of freedom. There is almost no traffic, so children can roam, and the days go on rock pools, crabbing from quays and boat trips to see seals. The trade-off is that nothing is built for children, and there is little to do on a wet day.
Getting around
Once you are there, Scilly is the easier of the two. Nobody needs a car, Hugh Town is compact, St Mary's has a small bus, and each off-island can be walked end to end in an hour or two. Getting there is the hard part: a long ferry crossing or a small plane that fog often delays, and inter-island boats that depend on the tide and the weather.
The Peak District is easy to reach by rail, with trains on the Hope Valley line and the branch lines to Buxton and Matlock, so a car-free walking trip is possible. Away from the stations, though, buses are sparse and most people drive narrow moorland roads. On sunny weekends, the car parks at Castleton and Dovedale fill up.
Shopping & style
On Scilly, shopping means a few gift and outdoor shops on Hugh Town's short main streets, plus small studios on the off-islands selling paintings, pottery and island-made gin. The most characteristic thing to take away is a box of scented narcissi, posted home from the flower farms in winter and spring.
The Peak District gives you a little more to browse. Hathersage has gear shops for walkers and climbers, Castleton sells jewellery made from Blue John, a stone mined only in its hills, and there are antiques in Ashbourne and Leek and Bakewell's weekly market. Neither place has any fashion shopping.
Affordability
The Peak District costs noticeably less. Prices are those of rural England, the hills are free to walk, and hostels, bunkhouses and campsites spread the choice of where to stay. The main extra costs are entry to the great houses and show caves.
On Scilly, costs add up quickly: the plane or ferry out, island hotels that charge a premium, food shipped in by sea and a boat fare for every day on another island. Self-catering cottages and the island campsites are the only real ways to keep spending down.
Live music & performing arts
The Peak District has the only real programme, thanks to Buxton. Its Edwardian opera house stages drama, comedy and concerts through the year, and in July the International Festival brings opera alongside a busy fringe. Summer concerts at the great houses add to that.
Scilly has no theatre or concert venue at all. Performances are limited to an occasional folk night in a pub or a concert in a church hall, so the evening's entertainment there is the sunset over the Western Rocks.
Wellness & relaxation
The Peak District has more to offer here because of Buxton's mineral springs. You can take the thermal water at the spa in the Crescent or fill a bottle at St Ann's Well, and country-house hotels across the dales have their own spas.
Scilly has no bathing tradition, and only a few hotel spas on Tresco and St Mary's, but it offers a deeper kind of quiet. With no cars, no crowds and days that follow the tides, it is easier to switch off there than in the Peak District's honeypot villages on a summer weekend.
When should you go?
Pick your month. The climate figures are measured averages, not a forecast.
Isles of Scilly in July
Peak District in July
Daytime high, °C
Rainfall in the month, mm
Where the figures come from
Isles of Scilly has no rain gauge within 25 km of the centre, so its rainfall comes from a gridded climate dataset read at the destination rather than from a gauge further away.
Isles of Scilly's sunshine is measured 78 km from the centre, at Camborne.
Peak District's temperatures are measured 43 km from the centre, at Manchester Airport.
Peak District has no rain gauge within 25 km of the centre, so its rainfall comes from a gridded climate dataset read at the destination rather than from a gauge further away.
Temperature and rainfall are climate normals, averaged over the years shown. Isles of Scilly: 1991-2020 normals, Scilly, Saint Mary'S (0.7 km from centre). Peak District: 1991-2020 normals, Manchester Airport (43.1 km from centre).
Scilly has the milder winters and the cooler summers. Daytime highs barely fall below 10°C even in January but only reach about 19°C in July and August. The sea is warmest in August, at around 17°C, so June to September is the only bathing season, and even then swims are brisk. May and June are the driest and sunniest months, and the best time for walking and wildlife trips. From October the Atlantic rain builds up, and November and December are wet and grey.
The Peak District is colder in winter, with snow on the high tops, and a little warmer in high summer, reaching about 21°C in July. Its rain is spread more evenly through the year, so summer is no drier than spring, and the wettest stretch is October to December at around 90mm a month. Late spring through to early autumn is the best time for walking. On both, the dark, damp months from November to February are best avoided unless you just want a quiet retreat.
Which traveller are you?
On a beach and sun trip, choose the Isles of Scilly without hesitation. The Peak District is a long way from any coast. Scilly has shell-sand bays with clear turquoise water, such as Par Beach and Pentle Bay, though the Atlantic stays cool enough that a wetsuit helps.
For a culture and arts trip, the Peak District has much more. It offers Chatsworth and Haddon Hall, Georgian Buxton with its Matcham opera house and July festival, and the Derwent Valley mills. Scilly's castles, prehistoric graves and Abbey Garden take two or three days to see.
On a trip with a tight budget, the Peak District is far easier on the wallet. The hills are free to walk, there are hostels and campsites throughout, and trains reach the walking villages. On Scilly, everything arrives by sea, the journey out is expensive, and every day on another island adds a boat fare.
Before you go
| Measure | Isles of Scilly | Peak District |
|---|---|---|
| Official language | English | English |
| Currency | Pound Sterling (GBP) | Pound Sterling (GBP) |
| Sockets | ||
| Driving side | Left | Left |
| Time zone | UTC, UTC+1 in summer | UTC, UTC+1 in summer |
| Emergency number | 112 or 999 | 112 or 999 |
| Main airport | St. Mary's Airport (ISC)2 non-stop destinations | Manchester Airport (MAN)211 non-stop destinations |
| Public holidays this year | 8 days | 8 days |
By the numbers
| Measure | Isles of Scilly | Peak District |
|---|---|---|
| Population | 2,281 | 35,901 |
| People per km² | 140 | 25 |
| Swim season, months above 21 °C | None | - |
Where else could you go?
Every comparison below shares a destination with this one, so you can follow Isles of Scilly or Peak District somewhere new.
- Yorkshire Dalesvs Peak District
- Cornwallvs Isles of Scilly
- Snowdoniavs Peak District
- Cotswoldsvs Peak District
- Lake Districtvs Peak District
- Devonvs Isles of Scilly