

Photos: St Thomas by MattWade, CC BY-SA 4.0, cropped; Puerto Rico by Mariordo (Mario Roberto Durán Ortiz), CC BY-SA 4.0, cropped.
St Thomas or Puerto Rico?
Our verdict in twelve categories, each scored against the same fixed benchmark cities, and the climate month by month, so you can choose for your trip.
Choose St Thomas for
- beaches
St Thomas is the better pick for a simple, unhurried beach and boat vacation. The sea is calm on its main beaches, St John's national park is a short ferry ride away, and sailing east through the Virgin Islands starts at Red Hook. In return you get very little city life, modest food and quiet evenings, and you pay some of the highest prices in the Caribbean.
Choose Puerto Rico for
- nightlife
- live music and the arts
- food and drink
Puerto Rico suits travellers who want more than a beach. It has a Spanish colonial old town with huge stone forts, a rainforest and glowing bays, roast pork in the hills, and salsa bars in San Juan that stay open into the small hours. It works best as a road trip, starting in the capital and then driving to the beaches, mountains and the quieter islands of Culebra and Vieques. It is also the cheaper of the two, though neither is a bargain.
Scoreboard
Twelve categories on one fixed scale from 0 to 100. The shaded stretch is the gap between the two.
Your match
Pick a travel style or drag the sliders, and both match scores follow your weighting.
Wins on beaches with your weighting.
Wins on nightlife and live music and the arts with your weighting.
What matters to you?
Category by category
What the scores mean for a trip.
Beaches & swimming
For beaches the two are evenly matched, but they offer different things. Puerto Rico has more coast and more variety. There are city beaches in Condado and Isla Verde, the calm bay at Luquillo, and Flamenco on Culebra, which is perhaps the best beach of all. From Isabela to Rincón, though, the Atlantic beaches see big waves and strong currents in winter, so you have to pick your spot.
St Thomas is calmer and smaller. Magens Bay and the beaches around Red Hook are sheltered enough for weak swimmers, you can snorkel straight off the sand at Coki Point, and St John's north shore bays are about twenty minutes away by ferry. The downside is that cruise passengers fill the best-known beaches.
Food & drink
Puerto Rico has much more to eat. Its creole cooking of mofongo, pasteles and arroz con gandules is everywhere, and the best eating is often outdoors: whole roast pig carved at the lechoneras of Guavate, and fritter stands at Piñones. Santurce adds creative kitchens, and the coffee haciendas in the central mountains offer tastings.
St Thomas has good West Indian food in its johnnycakes, pates, kallaloo and goat stew, plus seafood restaurants by the water in Frenchtown and Red Hook. Because nearly everything is imported, though, the choice is small and menus tend to repeat. It is a place where you eat well enough rather than a place you travel to for food.
Culture & sights
Old San Juan is the reason Puerto Rico wins here. Its five centuries of colonial streets, blue cobbles and huge forts above the sea can easily fill two days. Beyond the capital you can visit Ponce's art museum and plaza, the old church at San Germán, and the Taíno ball courts at Caguana and Tibes.
Charlotte Amalie is a pleasant contrast, with Danish rather than Spanish history: warehouses along narrow alleys, the 99 Steps, Fort Christian and a synagogue with a sand floor. It fills half a day to a day, and outside the town there is little else to see.
Nightlife
The gap here is wide. San Juan goes out late and in crowds. On weekend nights the street around La Placita fills with drinkers, the bars on Calle San Sebastián in the old town are packed and noisy, salsa and reggaeton dancing starts after midnight, and Isla Verde adds clubs and casinos.
St Thomas has no club scene. The busiest evenings are at the open-air bars by the Red Hook ferry dock, where boat crews and locals mix. Elsewhere, a night out is a drink at sunset in a beach bar, and Charlotte Amalie goes quiet once the cruise ships have left.
Nature & outdoors
Puerto Rico has more varied landscape. There is the rainforest of El Yunque with its tree ferns and waterfalls, three bays that glow blue-green when you paddle through them at night, and the Río Camuy caves under the karst hills near Arecibo. Rincón adds winter surf and passing humpback whales.
St Thomas has little wild land of its own, and most of its outdoors is out on the water. You can hike the national park trails on St John, snorkel among turtles and rays at Coki Point, and sail the sheltered channels to the east, which is where it beats Puerto Rico.
Day trips
Neither island is a great base for day trips, but Puerto Rico has more variety by land. Ponce is about an hour and a half by road, rum distilleries make an easy half day, and the coffee country lies inland. Culebra and Vieques are worth more than a day, and ferry delays are common, so plan to stay a night or two.
From St Thomas every outing is by boat. You can visit St John and Cruz Bay, quiet Water Island, St Croix's Danish towns, or the British Virgin Islands, which mean bringing a passport and clearing customs. The crossing is often half the fun, but the places themselves are all small islands.
Good for families
Puerto Rico gives families more to do. There is calm water at Luquillo and Seven Seas, short rainforest walks to natural pools, a guided route through the Camuy caves, and resorts with kids' clubs at Dorado and Río Grande. It has no zoo or aquarium, though, and the days involve a lot of driving.
St Thomas is easier to keep simple. Small children can swim safely at Magens Bay, and next to Coki Point, Coral World has touch pools and an underwater observatory, which Puerto Rico has nothing to match. Apart from that there is little else aimed at children, and the steep roads and per-person taxi fares make outings tiring.
Getting around
On both islands a car is close to essential, though Puerto Rico is a little easier. Its highways are good, the drive from San Juan to Rincón takes about two and a half hours, and you can walk Old San Juan and the Condado seafront. The difficult part is the ferry to Culebra and Vieques, which often sells out or runs late.
St Thomas reverses that. The St John ferry from Red Hook is frequent and easy, but getting around the island itself is harder: you drive on the left on steep, narrow roads, or use safari taxis that charge each passenger separately.
Shopping & style
Both are fairly ordinary for shopping, but people go for different things. In Puerto Rico you buy crafts: carved wooden santos, vejigante masks of coconut husk from Loíza or papier-mâché from Ponce, guayabera shirts and mountain coffee, with American malls in Hato Rey if you need them.
St Thomas is about duty-free buying. Main Street and the old warehouses in Charlotte Amalie sell jewellery, watches, perfume and spirits tax-free, with a generous customs allowance for US travellers. It suits a planned purchase more than an afternoon of browsing.
Affordability
Neither island is cheap, but St Thomas costs noticeably more. With nearly everything imported, its rooms, groceries and restaurant meals are among the priciest in the Caribbean, and per-person taxi fares add up quickly for a family.
Puerto Rico is priced like the American mainland, which is high but easier to manage. Roadside lechoneras, beach kiosks and the guesthouses around Rincón and the west coast keep the costs down, as long as you avoid the resorts and beachfront hotels in San Juan.
Live music & performing arts
Puerto Rico's music is its own, and you can hear it outside festival time. There is bomba drumming and dancing in Loíza and Piñones and at street gatherings in Santurce, plena sung around La Placita, and salsa bands playing for dancers in San Juan. For a seated evening, the Centro de Bellas Artes is home to the symphony orchestra, Teatro Tapia stages plays in Spanish, and the Casals Festival has a long classical tradition.
St Thomas has its own traditions in steel pan, calypso, quelbe and the stilt-walking mocko jumbies, but you see them at their fullest mainly during the spring Carnival. On most evenings, live music means a band at a beach bar, and the open-air Reichhold Center puts on concerts only now and then.
Wellness & relaxation
For relaxing the two are about level, and on both it mostly means a resort spa and a slower pace. Puerto Rico has an extra option in the old hot springs at Coamo, and the near-empty roads of Vieques and Culebra are about as restful as anywhere in the region.
On St Thomas, the calm comes from staying on the east end or the north shore, away from the harbour. On days when several cruise ships are in port, the capital and the best-known beaches lose their calm.
When should you go?
Pick your month. The climate figures are measured averages, not a forecast.
St Thomas in July
Puerto Rico in July
Daytime high, °C
Rainfall in the month, mm
Temperature and rainfall are climate normals, averaged over the years shown. St Thomas: 1991-2020 normals, C. Amalie / St. Thomas Airport (5.6 km from centre). Puerto Rico: 1991-2020 normals, San Juan / Int., Puerto Rico (8.3 km from centre).
Both islands are warm all year. Daytime highs are about 29°C in winter and 32°C from June to October, and the sea is warm enough for a swim in every month. Puerto Rico is the wetter of the two. February and March are its driest months, and March is also its sunniest. Showers become regular from April and peak in November at about 178mm. December stays damp and has the least sunshine of the year. St Thomas is fairly dry from January to July, and then the rain builds through late summer to a peak in November of about 159mm.
For a beach trip to Puerto Rico, aim for January to March. On St Thomas the good weather lasts longer, from December into early summer. The cooler winter months are also the best time to explore on foot, whether that means the hilly streets of Old San Juan or Charlotte Amalie's step streets. From June the midday heat makes walking tiring on both islands, so sightseeing is best done early or late in the day. Summer and autumn are also hurricane season on both.
Which traveller are you?
For a culture and arts trip, Puerto Rico is the clear choice. Old San Juan's forts and walls make up a UNESCO site, Ponce has a fine art museum, and bomba and salsa are easy to hear live. On St Thomas the heritage fills about a day in Charlotte Amalie.
On a food and nightlife trip, Puerto Rico is far ahead. You can eat at the roadside lechoneras of Guavate and the kitchens of Santurce, then spend a late night at La Placita or on Calle San Sebastián. St Thomas offers rum punch at Red Hook and an early night.
For a beach and sun trip built around calm water, St Thomas makes it simple. You can stay within walking distance of the east-end beaches, swim at Magens Bay and take the ferry to St John's bays. Puerto Rico's best sand is spread out, and its north coast has rough winter surf.
Before you go
| Measure | St Thomas | Puerto Rico |
|---|---|---|
| Official language | English | Spanish, English |
| Currency | US Dollar (USD) | US Dollar (USD) |
| Sockets | - | |
| Driving side | Left | Right |
| Time zone | UTC-4 | UTC-4 |
| Emergency number | 911 | 911 |
| Main airport | Cyril E. King Airport (STT)26 non-stop destinations | Luis Munoz Marin International Airport (SJU)59 non-stop destinations |
| Public holidays this year | 18 days | 21 days |
By the numbers
| Measure | St Thomas | Puerto Rico |
|---|---|---|
| Population | 42,261 | 3,285,874 |
| People per km² | 524 | 361 |
| Swim season, months above 21 °C | 12 months | 12 months |
Where else could you go?
Every comparison below shares a destination with this one, so you can follow St Thomas or Puerto Rico somewhere new.
- St Johnvs St Thomas
- British Virgin Islandsvs St Thomas
- Culebravs St Thomas
- Viequesvs St Thomas
- St Croixvs St Thomas
- US Virgin Islandsvs Puerto Rico


