

Photos: Finger Lakes by Andre Carrotflower, CC BY-SA 4.0, cropped; Napa Valley by Brocken Inaglory, CC BY-SA 3.0, cropped.
Finger Lakes or Napa Valley?
Our verdict in twelve categories, each scored against the same fixed benchmark cities, and the climate month by month, so you can choose for your trip.
Choose Finger Lakes for
- prices
- beaches
- families
The Finger Lakes suits travellers who want wine as one strand of a fuller trip. You get gorge walks past waterfalls, summer swims in clear lakes and nineteenth-century history at Seneca Falls and Corning, at prices that leave room for a week rather than a weekend. It is the better pick for families, and for anyone happy to drive from lake to lake.
Choose Napa Valley for
- wellness
- food and drink
- day trips
Choose Napa Valley when food, wine and being looked after are the whole point. Its cellars, the fine dining in Yountville and the mud baths and mineral pools of Calistoga are on a different level, and San Francisco is close enough for a day out. It is very expensive and does little for children, so it works best as a splurge for couples.
Scoreboard
Twelve categories on one fixed scale from 0 to 100. The shaded stretch is the gap between the two.
Your match
Pick a travel style or drag the sliders, and both match scores follow your weighting.
Wins on prices and beaches with your weighting.
Wins on wellness and food and drink with your weighting.
What matters to you?
Category by category
What the scores mean for a trip.
Beaches & swimming
Neither is a beach destination, but in the Finger Lakes swimming is part of a summer stay. There are state-park beaches at Geneva, Taughannock Point and Canandaigua, and in some years you can swim in pools beneath the waterfalls around Ithaca. The water is fresh, and the season runs only from late June to early September.
In Napa Valley a swim usually means the hotel pool. Lake Berryessa, over the eastern hills, is the one real option. The Sonoma coast makes a scenic drive, but the water there is cold and rough, not for swimming.
Food & drink
Both are wine regions first, but on very different scales. Napa Valley has the Cabernet estates along Highway 29 and the Silverado Trail, small cellars in the hills and an unusual concentration of fine dining in Yountville, so eating and drinking are the main event and every meal is an occasion.
The Finger Lakes pours cool-climate wines, Riesling above all, in relaxed tasting rooms that look over the water. Meals are farm-to-table, in winery restaurants and in Ithaca, Geneva and Canandaigua. There are fewer memorable restaurants and little choice in the villages, but eating simply is far easier than in Napa.
Culture & sights
The Finger Lakes has sights worth the trip: the Corning Museum of Glass, the Women's Rights National Historical Park at Seneca Falls, Harriet Tubman's home in Auburn and the Eastman photography museum in Rochester. They are spread across the region, but together they give a stay a strong thread of American history.
Napa's heritage lies in its stone wine cellars, the old Greystone building and the Bale Grist Mill. They make a pleasant background to tasting rather than a reason to come, and visitors who want serious museums head to San Francisco.
Nightlife
Both regions go to bed early, so neither is the place for a night out, though the Finger Lakes has slightly more going on. In term time Ithaca's college bars around Collegetown stay busy and the villages have brewpubs. Napa's evenings centre on the wine bars and cocktail bars along the river in downtown Napa, and further up the valley everything shuts soon after dinner.
Nature & outdoors
The Finger Lakes has the more striking scenery: glacial gorges cut into the shale, Watkins Glen with its nineteen waterfalls, the Ithaca falls a few minutes from town and Letchworth's canyon on the western edge. Add kayaking and sailing on the lakes and long cycling loops, and an outdoors trip has plenty to do.
Napa is gentler and more farmed, a valley floor of vineyards between oak-covered ranges. Its best-known outings are a dawn balloon flight and a bike ride on the Silverado Trail. For a proper walk there are Mount St. Helena and the redwoods of Bothe-Napa Valley.
Day trips
Napa has the better day trips, mainly because San Francisco is within reach, by road or partly by ferry from Vallejo. Berkeley and Sausalito are also close, and Sonoma, with its plaza and Spanish mission, is just over the hills. Beyond those, most outings are to other wine valleys.
From the Finger Lakes, most days out are to the next lake: Skaneateles, Hammondsport or Penn Yan, each with its own wine trail. The big exception is Niagara Falls, under two hours from Canandaigua, and Rochester and Syracuse are there when you want a city.
Good for families
The Finger Lakes is far easier with children. The Strong National Museum of Play in Rochester, Ithaca's Sciencenter, glassblowing at Corning, the gorge trails, lake beaches and pick-your-own farms fill summer days, though every outing means time in the car.
Napa is built around tasting rooms and long dinners, so families usually treat it as a short stop. Calistoga's small geyser, the petrified forest and the warm pools at the hot-springs resorts help, but hot afternoons and resorts made for adults limit what you can do.
Getting around
Both regions need a car, but the Finger Lakes is the easier of the two. Its roads are good and rarely busy, and the drives along the lakeshores are part of the pleasure. The one thing to plan for is that the lakes run north to south, so getting from one to the next means driving round the ends. Ithaca has a walkable centre and local buses, so you can leave the car for a day.
Napa is compact, about 50km from end to end, but Highway 29 slows down on weekends and at harvest time. The buses up the valley are too infrequent to plan tastings around, and only a few small downtowns can be explored on foot. In both regions, wine lovers often hire a driver or join a tour rather than drive between tastings.
Shopping & style
Napa has a little more to buy. Many estates sell bottles at the cellar door that are hard to find elsewhere and will ship them home by the case. St. Helena's Main Street has homeware and kitchen boutiques, Yountville has galleries, and there is an outlet centre on the edge of Napa town.
The Finger Lakes is more homespun, with studio glass in Corning's Gaslight District, bookshops on the Ithaca Commons and antique shops along the country roads. Most visitors take home Riesling and maple syrup. Neither region has much in the way of fashion.
Affordability
This is where the two differ most. Napa is one of the most expensive places to travel in the country: inns up the valley, tasting fees and dinners at the famous restaurants make even a careful stay a splurge. Staying in Napa town and picnicking only soften the cost.
The Finger Lakes is not cheap on summer and autumn weekends, but it has what Napa lacks: chain motels in the towns, state park campsites and cabins, gorge parks that charge little and farm stands. Weekdays and the shoulder months bring prices down further.
Live music & performing arts
Neither has a great deal, and what they have is quite different. The Finger Lakes relies mostly on Rochester at its northern edge, with concerts at the Eastman School, the Rochester Philharmonic and the June jazz festival. Closer in, there is summer theatre in Ithaca and Auburn and the GrassRoots roots-music festival in Trumansburg.
Napa's calendar is mostly seasonal and close at hand. A big rock and pop festival comes each late spring, and summer brings classical and jazz concerts at the wineries and in Yountville. All year round, downtown Napa has its restored opera house and an Art Deco theatre.
Wellness & relaxation
Napa is the clear choice for a restful trip. Calistoga was founded as a hot-springs resort, and its volcanic-ash mud baths and geothermal pools carry on that tradition. Around Yountville and the Silverado Trail there are more polished spas among the vineyards.
The Finger Lakes offers calm rather than treatments: a few inn spas at Skaneateles, Geneva and Canandaigua, retreat centres near Ithaca and slow mornings on the water. The old mineral springs at Clifton Springs no longer have a bathing tradition.
When should you go?
Pick your month. The climate figures are measured averages, not a forecast.
Finger Lakes in July
Napa Valley in July
Daytime high, °C
Rainfall in the month, mm
Where the figures come from
Finger Lakes's temperatures are measured 27 km from the centre, at Penn Yan.
Finger Lakes's station stands 163 m above the place it is measured for, so that place is likely a little warmer than the figures say.
Finger Lakes has no rain gauge within 25 km of the centre, so its rainfall comes from a gridded climate dataset read at the destination rather than from a gauge further away.
Finger Lakes's sunshine is measured 63 km from the centre, at Greater Rochester International.
Napa Valley has no rain gauge within 25 km of the centre, so its rainfall comes from a gridded climate dataset read at the destination rather than from a gauge further away.
Napa Valley's sunshine is measured 76 km from the centre, at Sacramento Executive Airport.
Temperature and rainfall are climate normals, averaged over the years shown. Finger Lakes: 2006-2020 (sunshine 1981-2010, rainfall 1991-2020) normals, Penn Yan (26.6 km from centre). Napa Valley: 1991-2020 (sunshine 1981-2010) normals, Napa / Middleton (21.9 km from centre).
The Finger Lakes has a short, warm summer and a long cold season. From June to September days are pleasant for walking and the lakes, with highs of about 28°C in July. The water is only good for swimming in July and August, when it reaches about 22°C. October is cooler but still good for walking, with the autumn colours at their peak. January and February stay near 1°C, and March and December are only a little milder. Rain is spread fairly evenly through the year, a little heavier from spring to autumn, so a showery day can come in any month.
Napa Valley's weather runs the other way. From May to October it is dry and much sunnier, with almost no rain from June to September and highs steady around 26°C, which makes afternoons among the vines hot. Winters stay mild but bring the rain, about 141mm in January. Spring and autumn are the most comfortable months for being outdoors.
Which traveller are you?
On a family trip with children, choose the Finger Lakes in summer. Rent a lakeside cottage and mix a museum morning with an afternoon on the water. In Napa, days are built around tasting and long dinners, so children spend much of the time waiting.
For a relaxing and wellness trip, Napa Valley is the better choice. Stay a few nights in Calistoga for the waters, and keep the wine to one slow afternoon. The Finger Lakes is peaceful, but it has little in the way of treatments.
On a tight budget, the Finger Lakes is the only realistic choice of the two. Its best days out, waterfall walks and swims in the lakes, cost very little, which leaves money for a tasting or a good dinner. In Napa, the wine and food are the trip, and both are priced as luxuries.
Before you go
| Measure | Finger Lakes | Napa Valley |
|---|---|---|
| Currency | US Dollar (USD) | US Dollar (USD) |
| Sockets | ||
| Driving side | Right | Right |
| Time zone | UTC-5, UTC-4 in summer | UTC-8, UTC-7 in summer |
| Emergency number | 911 | 911 |
| Main airport | Frederick Douglass Greater Rochester International Airport (ROC)25 non-stop destinations | San Francisco International Airport (SFO)143 non-stop destinations |
| Public holidays this year | 13 days | 13 days |
By the numbers
| Measure | Finger Lakes | Napa Valley |
|---|---|---|
| Swim season, months above 21 °C | 1 month | - |
Where else could you go?
Every comparison below shares a destination with this one, so you can follow Finger Lakes or Napa Valley somewhere new.
- Sonomavs Napa Valley
- Niagara Fallsvs Finger Lakes
- Lake Tahoevs Napa Valley
- Big Survs Napa Valley
- Catskillsvs Finger Lakes
- Yosemitevs Napa Valley
